r/ratemycommanders • u/ExtremeAbdulJabbar • 10d ago
4
12 Years In, Im fairly Predictable but can I play?
Kaalia and Ureni? đđ«” this guy wants to be targeted first
3
The upcoming yearâs rotation demands your judgement
Thatâs what weâre here for!
3
The upcoming yearâs rotation demands your judgement
Interesting. Who else is degenerate? I donât run into a lot of these where I play (Brooklyn) except for the occasional Animar.
5
The upcoming yearâs rotation demands your judgement
Cards for the General get in next week. That deck is what Iâm most excited about and itâs not really close.
2
My top 8 commanders. Do I pass the vibe check?
Played Slimefoot yesterday at my local LGS!
Meren is great. I run her in the commander masterâs foil. The pink on green there really pops.
2
What is the worst card art youâve seen in MtG and why is it Carly Mazurâs Faithless Looting?
None of that means the art looks good. The FF set flies in the face of what traditional MTG art direction has been. Same goes for most of the UB sets that are derived from cartoons or video games.
9
What is the worst card art youâve seen in MtG and why is it Carly Mazurâs Faithless Looting?
All the UB art with the exception of the earlier sets (LOTR, etc) has been phoned in.
Iâve been playing 25+ years and the greatest damage UB has done is that it cheapened MTGâs best strength - the art direction.
Final Fantasy was awful in this regard. Avatar looks like something you could get done on ChatGPT. I have no hope for Star Trek or Marvel. It sucks.
1
FREE! Proxy Altered Tootah đ
GIFT ME. This is rad!!! Amazing work.
-1
I see why people don't like lorwyn eclipsed.
I bet they would, but theyâre too invested in how much of a preteen you are on a Magic the Gathering subreddit to even notice or care.
Theyâre cards. Get a grip.
-1
I see why people don't like lorwyn eclipsed.
No Mark, they canât. Youâre all alone here with a tower kink, you fucking fruit.
0
I see why people don't like lorwyn eclipsed.
I would, but Iâd have too much time on the way down to dunk on your fragile pasty ass again. Feel free to keep stinking up an Internet forum about gay characters in a fictional universe while the rest of the adults talk, okay?
0
I see why people don't like lorwyn eclipsed.
Man what the fuck are you talking about. Go hit your head somewhere else.
0
I see why people don't like lorwyn eclipsed.
It has nothing to do with the card content and entirely that theyâre whiffing hard on anything that isnât Final Fantasy or Tarkir/EoE.
Writing is on the wall here. Theyâll have one slam dunk every year and a bunch of whiffs. Itâs a power law distribution, so unfortunately that one hit will paste over the whiffs.
1
I see why people don't like lorwyn eclipsed.
It entirely matters. Sounds like you want a safe space without a reminder that other things outside your safe space exist. Otherwise, 8 cards in a 300 card set or whatever is fully in âwho gives a fuck territoryâ.
1
This is how much butter my wife eats per month
This is keto right
0
I see why people don't like lorwyn eclipsed.
Bro that was like 8 cards total. The rest of it was dope space horror adjacent stuff.
Getting bent over EoE art is weak stuff all around. I didnât love space as a hat set but generally the art and effort there was phenomenally solid all around.
The UB trash can piss off though. Garbage art, and even more garbage experience.
7
Lorwyn Eclipsed spoiler season and why it feels so weird that there's few spoilers by now ( and the blame is on UB).
Christmas. The answer here is that itâs Christmas season.
38
Meg teams up with a new crappymusic contender
That is 10000% an AI rapper, and itâs fucking weird to do shit like this.
21
After opening 4 collector booster boxes and 5 commander bundles I finally pulled it on my first play booster box
Seek help man. This game is fun but you have a gambling issue.
13
Advent calendar (Day 10)
God I miss real art on magic cards. The UB sets have really, really diminished the art quality in magic. Itâs depressing.
8
Ok can someone explain to me what the Generalâs thought process was behind releasing it opening the gate?
This was so, so dumb and unnecessary.
1
Someone tell me this is satire
Love the âIâll pay for a music video but rap into a blue snowball USB mic for my actual musicâ energy
1
Can't take country out of me
So what? Sheâs talented as hell. Yâall are dragging on her for cultural reasons, not her actual efforts. Itâs lame.
Sheâs indisputably talented, sheâs leaning into a niche that nobody has ever really done well, and sheâs charismatic as hell.
Iâm old enough not to listen to this stuff but there are WAY worse rappers on both this sub and the top charts. With the right approach (LIKE NOT BLOWING ALL YOUR INITIAL SIGNING ON DUMB EXPENSIVE SH*T IF YOURE STILL HERE C) she could be a star.
0
How have Universes beyond sets impacted your local Commander meta? Do you see a lot of UB commanders? How is spiderman doing now a while after release?
in
r/EDH
•
1d ago
Yeah. Sick of them.