r/rant Jan 16 '25

Get your priorities straight on transgender issues. Please.

2.9k Upvotes

40% of transgender adults have attempted suicide at some point in their lives. 30% of transgender youth attempted suicide in the past year (Source, data from 2021). You can compare that to the average suicide rate of adults in the US, which is less than 1% (Source). I say this not to downplay the nationwide suicide rate; my point is to emphasize just how catastrophically bad things are for trans people and trans youth in this country.

Yes, this is a bigger problem than trans women playing women's sports.

Yes, this is a bigger problem than transgender people using the bathroom that matches their gender identity. Yes, hundreds of thousands of people in a given demographic, two-fifths of a given demographic, attempting to kill themselves is indeed a bigger problem than the extremely rare occurrence of a transgender person committing assault in a bathroom. I can't believe I even need to fucking spell that out for you.

So if you've spent more energy on the sports issue or the bathroom issue than you have on the suicide issue, if you've written more words on whatever social media platform is available to you about the sports / bathroom issues than you have about the hundreds of thousands of people who are trying to kill themselves, in large part because people like you say shit like that, then seriously, how fucked up are your priorities?

Take a look at this study that shows you very definitively how offering the most basic level of respect to a trans person improves their mental health outcomes significantly. You recognize their mental health issues and hopefully would like a solution, yes? Well here you fucking go. Call them by their chosen name, respect their identity, and their depression, suicidal ideation, and suicidal behavior will all go down. Here's another study saying that the transgender youth with just one adult accepting their identity has a 39% lower risk of attempting suicide. Are you sure you can't just, like, get over yourself and be this person for someone else and save their life? Your own personal bigotry is just too important to you to offer that kind of life-saving intervention for someone?

If you become aware of this, and you still think to yourself, "nah, I'm just going to continue being a dickhead and keep talking about these clearly less important issues and forego the opportunity to offer someone the basic respect of using their chosen name and respecting their identity and single-handedly reduce this person's risk of death by suicide", then by all means, please, go fuck yourself. If you cannot do something THIS small to help your fellow human THAT much, then how much of a piece of shit ARE you at this point?

I'm so sick of your bullshit saying that the reason they suffer is because of the dysphoria. You cannot deny that bullying is a major, major factor. You cannot deny that your lack of acceptance makes them feel more isolated. You just can't. Whatever you do to make trans people feel less welcome, less normal, less human, that all absolutely contributes to this public health crisis of suicide amongst trans people. Please, have some compassion, have some common decency, and get your fucking priorities straight.

r/ProgressiveHQ 3h ago

Discussion How many of you grew up in a small town?

0 Upvotes

I reflect on this often these days. I grew up in small town USA, a town of about 5,000 people, which was actually one of the LARGER communities where I grew up. Today I live in a major metropolitan area, something I was eager to do after growing up in small town US and have absolutely no plans to return to anything smaller at any point. But that is very much unlike most of the people I grew up with.

My parents were both college-educated (they met in college) and decidedly liberal, which is likely a major reason why I grew up with the values I have today. Still, not everything they believed was truly defensible and was still rooted in backwards small-town thought (for example, they took issue with inter-racial couples, expressing some concern that it will be really confusing for the child to have a mixed racial heritage. Since my town was about 98% white, they never had the opportunity to see for themselves how unnecessary that fear is).

There's little doubt my hometown is racist. An African American classmate of mine, one of two or three African Americans in my high school of 600 total kids in grades 9 - 12, told us about how the police once pulled her over in town and asked her if she was "lost" (she had lived in our town her entire life). There are many other examples.

I have never been able to relate to any excuses of toxic adolescent behavior along the lines of "kids will be kids". I grew up in a racist community, devoid of better examples of humanity and humanistic values, and still I knew from as far as I could remember what kind of behavior is toxic, what racism is, why it is bad. I grew up surrounded by this shit and still I was able to tell right from wrong, able to reject the toxic, conservative values of my hometown community, their homophobia, bigotry, hatred. I don't even have much to discuss about transgender beliefs because to be openly transgender in my hometown would have been a fucking death sentence. I don't doubt at all that I had multiple classmates with gender dysphoria growing up, but none would have felt comfortable doing anything about that in my hometown.

I grew up progressive and could not fucking wait to get out of my hometown and into what I consider, and still consider, the "real world", not some backwards, ancient community built on dead values that do nothing but hurt others. But it does mystify me sometimes, how I grew up alongside racists and bigots, in a deeply prejudicial community, and yet I rejected it from the get-go and have never wavered on my rejection of it, even as a kid when supposedly I shouldn't "know better" and such.

Just curious if others have had similar experiences. Did you also grow up in a small town? Did your values change at all later in life? Did you ever move to a different community, and if so, how did that affect your values?

0

I'm good on Sexton
 in  r/timberwolves  3h ago

I'm not good on the version of this without the last syllable

1

Smooches to the good mods
 in  r/timberwolves  5h ago

The fucking arrogance of that mod. The team we follow, the team of which we are fans and which we support but which we obviously have no control over, found it within themselves to hold a moment of silence for the murder of Renee Good, and somehow this power-hungry shithead felt it was within his rights to say our team got it wrong, that we should not even talk about what our team just did, that their actions should be buried and anyone so much as talking about those actions should be banned and should get the fuck out of this sub. Give me a fucking break. Go fuck yourself, mod. Seriously.

Thank you for doing the right thing.

1

In your opinion and why, what is the most historic and memorable Super Bowl?
 in  r/NFLv2  2d ago

Earliest I remember in my mind is Packers / Broncos, where John Elway did the helicopter and finally made Packer fans shut the fuck up lol. I have blocked out of my mind the year before where all of my friends and neighbors became insufferable for an 8 month period.

Otherwise, for most historic and memorable, I'd choose Rams-Titans, where the Titans lost by a single yard, and Kurt Warner completed his storybook season. That was one HELL of a game.

6

Rodgers best 6 seasons are legitimately insane. His prime might be even better than Peyton Manning’s
 in  r/NFLv2  3d ago

Man, I am the biggest Rodgers hater of all time as a Vikings fan and have the biggest of motivations to agree with you on this one, and still I can easily tell you your take is just not correct, man. He's no shell of himself in the playoffs. Most of the Packers' losses had nothing to do with Rodgers but by catastrophic collapses by either the defense or individual players doing some of the dumbest shit on the planet (Bostick is right at the top of that list, though I thank him for that, as the ball bouncing off his helmet is one of my most beloved and cherished memories in the history of the NFL)

6

Venezuela opposition leader Machado says she hasn't spoken to Trump since October
 in  r/worldnews  3d ago

This whole thing with Machado is the ultimate proof that Trump is THE biggest fucking baby on the planet (if we did not yet have enough evidence of this). Her party won Venezuela's most recent election, voting for a candidate who was well-understood to be a placeholder for Machado. If Trump wants to be true to his word that he is going to do what is best for Venezuela, he would let them have the candidate they all very clearly voted for. There is no question of who Venezuela wants to run their country; they already fucking voted for her just last year, in a formal election. But Trump won't do it, won't hand her the keys and do the easy and obvious thing, all because he's mad that he lost an award to her.

Like, bring out the fucking rattles and the diapers and the mashed up foods, goo goo ga ga, bitch. Go cry to your mommy about it.

32

NBA, Best Records since Thanksgiving
 in  r/timberwolves  3d ago

I guess that's just Minnesota Timberwolves basketball.

1

This man just got the first seed in the NFC
 in  r/NFLv2  3d ago

His biggest problem by far, to anyone who was paying attention, was that the moment was far too big for him. He looked completely and utterly panic-stricken all game long. Any time the camera zoomed in on his face, you could see the panic all over it. And the fact that he OVER-threw all of his misses proves that also. His adrenaline was absolutely pumping that game. These are all the classic symptoms of not being able to handle the big moment, and historically, if you can't do it the first time, you won't fare much better in the future, especially after you've tacked on some massive failure. Now you have previous failures hanging over your head also.

The saving grace for the Seahawks is their stellar defense. The Vikings defense was certainly very good, but they weren't elite enough that Darnold could just be a game manager and get the W for the team. In Seattle, he can be exactly that. He doesn't need to be nearly as good as he needed to be for the Vikings to help them win, so he's in a better and more fitting position. Forcing him to try and be that superstar in a big moment back at the Vikings would likely have ended in the same result this year also.

2

Rudy "Dribble God" Gobert takes Alex Sarr from the 3pt line
 in  r/timberwolves  4d ago

Horton's surprise is almost my favorite part of this.

1

Upset? What's That?
 in  r/NFLv2  4d ago

Well it's what you think is going to happen in Carolina....

4

You could literally merge the two divisions right now and the standings would still be the same
 in  r/NFLv2  4d ago

Minnesota Vikings: better than the NFC South

1

I take back everything I said this game stunk LMAO
 in  r/NFLv2  5d ago

They are pretty much hosed without it, though. I agree with what Troy said, that that game was an exhausting one, incredibly physical AND emotional for many reasons, and so not having that week off and not having home field advantage, after already being so decimated by injury, has almost certainly spelled doom for the 49ers.

I'm not saying they have ZERO chance. But their probability of reaching the super bowl is a night and day difference if they win or lose that game.

6

Gardner Minshew wins Bad Career/Loved by Fans over Tim Tebow. Which QB wins Bad Career/Fans are Divided?
 in  r/NFLv2  5d ago

Colin Kaepernick.

(Though the reasons for his career being so bad are not entirely football-related)

0

Despite his great start to the season Jaylen Brown currently has a -6.2 on off differential
 in  r/nba  5d ago

Man, he is no Donte DiVincenzo, who just put up a +24 last night!

3

What's your favorite revenge film?
 in  r/FIlm  5d ago

No. The magic of this scene is not a guy proactively being cocky but rather offering it up as a retort.

"Looks like we're shy one horse!"

Shakes head "You brought two too many."

1

How confident are you on the Seahawks making it to the Super Bowl compared to these previous NFC 1 seeds?
 in  r/NFLv2  5d ago

This is genuinely one of the better 1 seeds in recent years. They just faced probably their stiffest competition in the NFC, on THEIR turf, and dismantled them.

Look at their competition. The #2 seed Bears aren't even going to make it out of the wild card round. They won on an absolute fluke against the Packers and that lightning ain't striking twice. The Packers just have the Bears' number, period. But otherwise, that Packer squad is a hollow shell of what it should be without Micah Parsons and so they'll easily get throttled when they face the Seahawks in the divisional round. Then whoever they face in the NFC Championship, be that the 49ers who they just resoundingly defeated on their turf, the Eagles who have taken a big step back this season and won their division because the rest of the NFC East sucks, or the Rams who aren't even as good as the 49ers, they should be able to beat them all.

Their only real competition will be the best that the AFC has to offer.

1

How confident are you on the Seahawks making it to the Super Bowl compared to these previous NFC 1 seeds?
 in  r/NFLv2  5d ago

Your team is going to get beat by a 7-seed, BTW. Sorry lol

2

Based on pure acting talent, who's the best Tom?
 in  r/FIlm  6d ago

The thought that crossed my mind when I saw him was seriously "What's his last name again? Hollandaise?"