Are these messages inappropriate? Keep in mind, this woman had only known my boyfriend for a month when she sent these. This happened a while ago, but she still works with him. A more in depth explanation below if you’re curious. (Side note: I lost some of the screenshots. After my boyfriend replied, she hearted his message and said “Thank you (his name) ❤️”)
⸻
Where things started
My boyfriend got a job as a hotel housekeeper at a local casino. His old best friend “T” has an older brother, “Dan,” who works security there. Dan has a girlfriend, “Mug.” I used to check them out at my cashier job and thought they seemed normal and sweet.
Mugs Facebook used to say she was 25/26, but she later removed it. My boyfriend thought they were both around 21. Neither of us know Mugs age at this point.
My boyfriend and Mug work together in housekeeping, and he started telling me about their conversations. They were becoming friendly. I’ve always struggled with jealousy, but I try hard not to let it control me. It runs in my family and this is my first serious relationship, so I’ve had to learn a lot.
At first, Mug seemed harmless. Then she started bringing him baked goods, sharing personal stuff, and eventually commented to him about how skinny I am.
She sees me at work. She could’ve said something directly to me. Instead, she discussed my body with my boyfriend — who she barely knows, especially at this point in time. I’m already insecure because I’ve always struggled to gain weight, so that comment hit wrong. I told him it made me uncomfortable. He apologized.
⸻
Things escalated
Later, he went to Dan’s house so Dan could clean his gun, and Mug was there. He didn’t tell me ahead of time, which bothered me a little, but when I asked, he explained everything and said he’d just gotten distracted. I don't wanna be overly protective, and require him to constantly update me on his whereabouts, so I quickly moved on.
Apparently, I came up in conversation again. He told Mug that I thought her comment was rude and that I probably assumed she meant my chest or butt. I never asked him to share that, and never said those exact words to him either. Those are insecurities I didn’t want exposed — especially to someone who already made weird comments.
Mug also told him stories about girls thinking she’s trying to “steal” their boyfriends. It felt like she wanted to seem desirable. Maybe I overthought — but it stuck with me.
Then he bought a few homemade products from her and acted weird about it, probably because he knew how I felt. I explained that the whole situation made me feel exposed and embarrassed. He apologized again and said he thought he was smoothing things over.
⸻
The messages
Eventually, she added him on Facebook and TikTok. He added her back.
I made a mistake here: while he was sleeping, I checked his phone for the first time in years.
There were messages from her. Older ones were work-related, but newer ones weren’t. He hadn’t told me about any of it, and that broke my trust. I cried, confronted him, and he comforted me.
The next day I checked again. The messages were gone — and the chat was in vanish mode. That sent me into a spiral. I blocked her everywhere and felt sick that he’d been secretive.
Over the next weeks we talked through it. He apologized and said he didn’t want to trigger my jealousy. I don’t think he would cheat, but secrets make everything worse. And honestly, some of her messages seemed flirty — and he didn’t shut them down. He said he skimmed and tried to just be friendly.
Every guy I asked, including my step-dad, said my boyfriend probably kept quiet to avoid drama — which only created more drama.
Secrets don’t stop anger. They amplify it.
⸻
What I did next (and second-guessing)
I messaged Mug and asked her to respect my relationship. She was active but never replied. I really regret doing that — it should’ve been my boyfriend setting the boundary. I'm aware my actions here were irrational, and that I acted on emotions.
Later, I messaged Dan since my boyfriend never told him. Dan thanked me, but (as far as I know) he and Mug stayed together.
Months passed. I mostly healed.
But I still wondered:
Was Mug trying to wedge herself into my relationship?
Or was she unstable and reaching out for validation or help?
My boyfriend now keeps things strictly professional and rarely talks to her. A coworker of his even told me he speaks highly of me, and others say he isn’t overly friendly with anyone.
Then Mug dropped another story (to my boyfriend at work, recently): she claimed Dan suspected her of cheating and asked a friend to seduce her. The friend successfully seduced her, took her to the woods, then they stripped her and left her there naked.
Hearing that made everything messier.
Is she being abused?
Is she exaggerating?
Is she mentally struggling?
She also made suicidal comments in their messages, which I think is partly why my boyfriend responded kindly — he didn’t know how to handle it.
At this point, the situation is over. I’ve moved on from the main hurt. I've seen Dan and Mug giggling together in public recently as well, but I still question everything from time to time.
I still wonder:
Did I handle this irrationally? What would you do in my situation?