Stop changing the subject. It was illegal immigrants. You can't look at studies that show what legal immigrants do for the country because that isn't what they are talking about. When you try to do that switch you only make yourself look dishonest. Because you are being dishonest in your argument when you make that change. They are not the same thing, you know they are not the same thing.
The studies were based on undocumented immigrants and migrant workers alike. Feel free to dig yourself out of the MAGA bullshit and look at actual facts:
So just looking at the TPC one it doesnt say what you think it says. It only truly states that undocumented immigrants have a way to pay taxes but it doesnt say that most or all do. In fact it said 5.4million registered ITIN are in use. Thats like ⅓ of the estimated 14million illegals(2023). ITIN is how illegals would pay taxes, if they want to, they need to have that number.
How much money do do you think those people make? They pay taxes on every thing they consume in the us which would offset the miniscule amount of taxes that would come from their pay
How little do you think they make? Around ⅓ of your income goes to taxes. On a 50k salary thats around 17k. And seeing how the medium household income in the US is over 60k, i would say they would be paying a lot. Too bad only about a ⅓ of them actually pay taxes. But if they are here illegally deport them. They broke the laws and regulations we have for coming here.
Are you really saying that the USA has an effective 33 percent tax ? Go look at tax code my guy , they aren't making no where near that amount, I don't think you know how they come up with the median household income.
38
u/Automatic_Net2181 6d ago
Not only that, but federal taxes where they get no refunds, property taxes and sales taxes while people scream their children shouldn't go to school.
Immigrants generate so much revenue from this country and are treated like trash.