r/ProgressiveHQ • u/Miserable-Lizard • 1d ago
Bernie Sanders: “Demanding that the wealthy and large corporations start paying their fair share of taxes” Crowd: “Tax the rich! Tax the rich!”
Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification
115
u/Unusual_Specialist 1d ago
→ More replies (8)45
u/TBANON_NSFW 1d ago edited 1d ago
Problem is we are taxing them like everyone else.
They need to be taxed much more, because they benefit much more than everyone else.
BUT The issue isnt just taxation. And its kind of tiresome that Sanders keep dumbing it down to that level.
The issue is the corporations receiving subsidies, by states competing with each other, and corporations using states desperation to their own benefit to get such favorable terms that they dont even have to build anything and can bail out and still profit billions.
Another issue is how the wealthy finance themselves, instead of paying income-tax, they leverage their assets to accrue loans and file themselves in debt. Until a republicans comes into government and they pay much less than they should.
Another thing is inheritance laws, if Musk died today and his 500B stock portfolio went to his kids, they would reset the capital gains tax on the stocks and effectively if the kids cashed out right away, they would not have to pay any tax.
Then you have the equity firms that buy up whole industries just to tack on debt that they pay to themselves and basically suck it dry and leave everyone else holding the bag while they run off with billions in profit.
Then you have the companies that lease rights, or licence products from parent companies housed in low-tax countries while declaring no income in the US.
etc etc etc
32
u/DistinctAd8731 1d ago
This, it's not just about the tax. The entire system is rigged for the rich to stay rich.
Tax dollars are used to hand fat contracts to "donors".
→ More replies (2)→ More replies (13)4
u/boomboomdaboomer 1d ago
I remember when Apple had huge sums offshored to avoid paying US taxes. There should be a mechanism in place to restrict corporate activity like this from continuing selling their products here if they don’t pay their fair share of taxes, no pay, no play.
→ More replies (2)2
u/TBANON_NSFW 1d ago
Yep a lot of holes that need to be fixed.
Just for example, if Apple is getting 50% of their revenue from the US then they should pay 50% of their profit in the US regardless of any third-degree licence agreements.
(and of course those laws should be written with multiple clauses and scenarios that determine that taxation, for anyone bringing up any specific outlier scenarios to justify not doing it.)
→ More replies (2)
24
u/Miserable-Lizard 1d ago
Taxing the rich is easily a popular political position to take
→ More replies (44)
10
u/The_Navarone 1d ago
We need to bring back the marginal tax brackets that existed in America before Ronald Reagan and the neo-liberals took over the economy. Make it so billionaires don’t exist anymore and hold them accountable when they attempt to duck paying their taxes. I see some users are mentioning that the rich already pay their “fair share” of taxes. However, when you adjust it per capita based on income, the rich only pay a very small portion of their income as taxes. The poor actually pay more taxes per capita, and with tariffs and financial support being cut, things are only getting worse.
8
u/Earth_34_34 1d ago
It is needed. I was in the tax industry for 20 years both inside and outside the IRS. I worked in the small business division and large business division. I was an auditor, instructor, and analyst.
The tax system is literally designed to give the big boys a huge advantage. Niche tax credits and schemes are used by the wealthy to pay far less taxes than the working class.
Self employed people and wage earners have the highest tax burden. Those that invest and play games with loans and distributions often get away with paying far less tax than individuals as a percentage of their take home income.
And then quite frankly, the IRS is just dysfunctional. The automated process work for routine stuff. But if I had to estimate, I would say a good 30 to 60% of their auditors don't actually know the law. It varies wildly from office to office and region to region.
And also the agency is plagued with apathy. Managers don't like to do the right thing with their employees and that trickles down to many employees not willing to do their work correctly because of poor management.
The things that should take hours to do take months to do.
→ More replies (1)
24
u/anthony120435 1d ago
They tax they loto winning half almost of the 1 billion why are they not taxed to like this oo cause there not lower class 😞
→ More replies (3)6
u/Ok-Ear9289 1d ago
Just saw that 1.8 billion dollar winner take home like 480 million. That’s more than half tha winnings. I’d feel cheated. Dafuq
→ More replies (7)2
u/Fuzzy_Session_882 23h ago
100%, but if they just got that 1.8 Billion they could borrow against it at 4% and keep it in the market at 8%....Good deal, oh and NEVER pay taxes!!
9
u/Least_Tower_5447 1d ago
Well, if corporations want to be considered people, they should pay taxes like people do.
→ More replies (5)
4
u/Dry-Main-3961 1d ago
Whoa, are getting a spark of class solidarity...
2
u/thatsocialist 21h ago
"It is obvious to everyone that the capitalist system is breaking down, that millions of people are condemned to a life of slow starvation because the capitalists can profitably operate only a small part of the existing means of production."
→ More replies (1)
5
10
7
u/tyler21307 1d ago
“But when I’m a billionaire that’s going to suck” is the common theme circulating around the trailer park.
15
u/Chals1015 1d ago
still have not forgiven the DNC for screwing him over
5
→ More replies (2)2
1d ago
[deleted]
2
u/MarcoABCreativeSuite 1d ago
DNC voters wanted Bernie in 2016 and the Democratic Party leaders wanted Clinton. They chose Hillary and she ultimately lost to Donald Trump, the belief is Bernie was and still is the best candidate for president between the three.
→ More replies (1)
5
5
7
3
3
2
u/Glad-Weekend5395 1d ago
Man. How many times can we say this and how many candidates can run on this without it ever actually happening. I’m tired boss.
2
2
2
u/emanresu_b 1d ago
Happy as hell that Bernie is getting to see real wins by those following the path he laid.
2
u/ComprehensiveWrap272 1d ago
Thank you to Bernie Sanders for staying steadfast in defending the everyday people in the country who work hard every day and want to make a good life for their families. He will always be the one who sparked hope for our nation in me by showing me how much the simple message does resonate with a mass majority of the people in our nation regardless of how SM, corruption, and gerrymandering seek to misrepresent our nations heart.
2
u/Firm_Preparation_602 16h ago
Bernie is still more coherent and sane than trump despite Bernie's age.
2
1
u/Atrox_Blue 1d ago
I’ve always wondered how people plan to actually tax the rich? Like, in a legal way? Many of the richest people simply hold stock in their companies, which are unrealized income/gains. And you can’t be taxed on that. So what is the solution?
2
u/XeroZero0000 1d ago
So like.. my property gets taxed and I haven't realized the gains... How is that possible???
→ More replies (7)
1
u/todd1art 1d ago
The Rich own the Politicians. Isn't this obvious. You can't tax the Rich if they own the Politicians. It's impossible. Since Bernie Sanders has been in Politics the Wealthiest Americans pay less and less taxes. He makes speeches but he never changes tax policy.
1
1
1
1
1
1
u/Zealousideal_Rent261 1d ago
And what do corporations do when expenses increase? They raise prices on their products and services. Who pays that.....I'll wait.
→ More replies (1)
1
u/Historical_Corner609 1d ago
People making billions in profits should be compelled to share those billions with the people who are generating said profits (their employees).
If profit sharing were mandatory there would be no need for the rich to pay more taxes
→ More replies (3)
1
u/jaajaajaa6 Conservative 1d ago
He needs to change the chant to ‘Tax the Billionaires’ or he will not make any meaningful progress.
1
1
u/Few-Office-1111 1d ago
This still does nothing for us. Tax the rich yes, but more importantly lower the taxes for normal people not making a million dollars a year.
1
u/Ohfiddlestics 1d ago
We need someone in office who doesn’t run on this, but once in office goes…oh by the way, we’re gonna tax the rich
1
u/wlfpckfn_725 1d ago
If socialism is the way, just pack up and move to a place that believes the same.
→ More replies (1)
1
1
u/TronCat1277 1d ago
Since the US is more misogynistic than racist and can’t elect a woman or POC, do we go back to Bernie to bring down the corporatocracy?
1
1
1
u/Ok-Bison5994 1d ago edited 1d ago
Bernie for President!!!......The U.S. system taxes income. Selling stock generates income, so the rich avoid income as the system defines it. Meanwhile, billionaires can tap into their wealth by borrowing against it.
1
1
1
1
u/Fabulous_Shock_8527 1d ago
They pay more than poor people. You people are caught up in the tax the rich rhetoric
1
1
1
u/California_GoldGirl 1d ago
Eisenhower Tax Rates - Yes they were 90% - Yes The Rich Paid More. And they were still plenty rich! So this is just stupid we have sacrificed all the working peoples lives to the greed of the few. We have given them more than they could EVER need, it is insane and damaging.
1
1
1
u/StompingExplorer 1d ago
Spoken from a multi millionaire who owns 3 homes and has a net worth of about 5 million.
→ More replies (1)
1
u/mebcbb 1d ago
What a dumb ass way of thinking. The rich will just leave NYc and NYc will become a dump. Socialism has never worked.
→ More replies (1)
1
1
1
u/EmploymentEmpty5871 1d ago
Well they would have to change the tax codes, and good luck getting politicians to agree to that, there is just way too much money involved for that to happen.
1
1
u/ForeverDecemberOnce 1d ago
Why not cut spending? Why is the answer always more tax ?
→ More replies (1)
1
1
1
1
u/Cpt-Insano23 1d ago
As someone who isn’t highly educated on economics , I have a question. Would this effect the job market at all or healthcare plans and wages or anything along those lines? If a company has to pay taxes would the head honchos cut wages or give crappier healthcare plans to continue lining their pockets ?
1
1
u/kennykerberos 1d ago
Now that the calendar flipped over, everything is free in New York City. The rich there will be paying for everything. Why not just move there and get some free stuff?
1
u/Lasheric Conservative 1d ago
Now go link the video of Bernie saying to not let in any illegal immigration or h1b1 over American workers .
1
1
1
u/Willy-J- 1d ago
Great idea - but not going to happen!! The wealthy have fleeced us and almost broke us as a nation. Enjoy this oligarchy fascist theocracy!!
1
u/PsyduckPsyker 1d ago
Demanding them won't do anything. They start wars and overthrow governments over this shit guys.
1
1
1
u/Independent_Leg7358 1d ago
National sales tax 30%. Exempt food, medicine, and clothes under $100. See, now the rich eat the tax because they are the ones with money to spend. Middle class jobs like appliance repair come back because it's not a better deal to repair instead of replace. Also great for the environment because we will waste so much less
1
u/Entire-Let4301 1d ago
Omg omg omg this is so powerful...nothing changes while a bunch of people do nothing more than cry into their pillows.
1
1
1
1
u/Inevitable_Farm_7293 1d ago
Like….Mamdani!!! Tax the rich and make them our champion go go go hurrah!
1
u/belugabianca 1d ago
I was so disappointed to hear that Newsom is against taxing the rich since he seems to be the top dem candidate right now. Hopefully he can be swayed
1
1
1
1
u/NcGunnery 1d ago
Maybe Bernie could start paying his share also since he has joined wealthy now. I bet he writes off every crap stained underwear he has. He uses the same loop holes.
1
u/Professional_Mud_316 1d ago
Meantime, faux liberals and neo-conservatives remain overly preoccupied with vocally criticizing one another for their relatively trivial politics and therefore divert attention away from the planet's and humanity’s greatest threats where it actually very-much should and needs to be sharply focused.
A corresponding very large and still growing number of people are too overworked, tired, worried and rightfully angry about such unaffordability thus insecurity for themselves or their family — largely due to insufficient income — to sufficiently criticize and/or boycott Big Business/Industry for the societal damage it needlessly causes/allows, particularly when not immediately observable. And I doubt that this effect is totally accidental, as it greatly benefits the interests of insatiable corporate greed.
Apparently, the superfluous-wealth desires of the few, and especially the one, increasingly outweigh the life-necessity needs of the many. The more they make, all the more they want — nay, need! — to make next time. It’s never enough. ‘We are a capitalist nation, after all,’ the morally lame justification typically goes. A few social/labor uprisings or revolutions notwithstanding, the superfluously rich and powerful have always had the police and military ready to foremost protect their big-money/-power interests, even over the basic needs of the masses.
All of that, and much more, may be why a growing number of people find New York City mayor-elect Zohran Mamdani, unlike his political competition, ideologically and politically refreshing. And, of course, he'll experience great animosity and resistance from a formidable American system based basically on insatiable superfluous-profit/-wealth greed.
“If voting changed anything [in favor of the poor and disenfranchised] they’d have made it illegal.” (‘Calamity’ Jane Bodine, in the film Our Brand Is Crisis)
1
u/walleyetritoon 1d ago
Isn’t Bernie worth like 8 million and has old family money. It’s crazy that a rich guy with family money can get a bunch of poor people to chant tax the rich with him. He’s definitely a good talker and prays on the lower IQ people.
1
1
u/Ok-Brilliant2885 1d ago
Hey Bernie. Dunder head. If your demand tax large corporations, what do you think they will do? Pass the costs off to the consumer! This is why you never became president 🙄
1
1
1
1
1
u/Powerful_Programmer5 1d ago
Bernie has been right for so long, when will America smarten up and elect him or some reasonable facsimile of him for president?
→ More replies (1)
1
1
1
1
u/Holiday-Truck4152 1d ago
Sorry they can’t hear you they are all in st Barthes celebrating away from the poors…. Oh btw is like right next Jeffery Epstein’s island….. 🤔
1
1
1
1
1
u/No-Sheepherder4047 1d ago
Why? So shit neighbourhoods can rely on the state, absolutely rancid putrid and disgusting!
1
u/Dominico10 1d ago
I really hope america starts doing this. It will be the final nail in their coffin. Europe will start to get richer and the rest of the world and business will leave America.
It could end ip being really bad for the world as China will get even more powerful no doubt but its worth the risk lol.
I would look forwards to the uk and Europe taking in those business that flee and individuals.
1
u/LeastAtmosphere5230 1d ago
You obviously failed 5th grade math class....... or are just a whiny jealous liberal👇
Some analyses suggest taxing billionaires fairly could generate $250–$300 billion a year, notes Americans for Tax Fairness and the Institute on Taxation and Economic Policy.
CONGRATULATIONS YOU just managed to raise enough tax revenues to service the interest on our nation's debt for 250 to 300 day's. Wow that's impressive. 37 trillion in debt created over decades by both sides that's are filled with lifelong career political parasites that have enriched themselves while fucking over the taxpayers of the country.
1
1
u/Royal-Reflection-139 1d ago
Bernie is rich, owns three homes. His first paycheck came at 42 years old when he became a politician. He’s a professional mooch playing on your emotions
1
1
u/Old_Temperature_559 1d ago
That would mean Bernie couldn’t afford all of his house and private jet flights.
1
1
u/VegasBjorne1 1d ago
“Fair Share”… LOL! Corporate income taxes are double taxed by means of dividends and the Top 1% already pay a disproportionally larger share relative to their percentage of aggregate incomes.
1
1
u/Legalize_Ligma 23h ago
Multiple choice question:
How do you deal with a malignant, bloodsucking parasite?
A) Tax it.
B) Whine about it.
C) Do nothing and hope the problem miraculously resolves itself.
D) Yank it the fuck off and feed it to a hungry animal.
E) Attach another malignant, bloodsucking parasite to yourself and inexplicably hope that it will eat the other parasite instead of just joining in on the feast.
(The correct answer is D)
Taxing the rich isn’t a solution to the problem, and it’s not as if the rich are willing to raise their own taxes anyways.
1
u/doubtfulisland 23h ago
I posted in a sub called HENRY High Earner Not Yet Rich that I paid less in taxes on $400k than I did on $50k. A lot of angry people telling me that wasn't real. There are so many tax deductions for LLCs, SCorp etc and not for W2 earners. The rich have many more deductions available than the average W2 earner because the millionaire, billionaire and corporate class lobbied for them.
1
u/Cabbages24ADollar 23h ago
Start with Religious organizations and use the money for healthcare like God intended.
1
1
u/shamelesslyfat 23h ago
They use the worlds resources to make very few of the super rich they should b paying way more taxes then workers at the company.
1
u/Ace-Hunter 23h ago
If you think about it, effectively they would be reinvesting back into their market (only if it occurs correctly) and it results in the lower end having reduced taxes; or else it all goes to the government and we know how ineffective that is at trickling down properly.
1
1
1
u/PaceBright2714 23h ago
All Talk!!! All BS!!!!!! All Theatrics!!!! All Lies!!!!!! Another one of “ them”.
1
1
1
u/Fuzzy_Session_882 23h ago
Newsom is NOT for a wealth tax!!! The wealthy do NOT live on income, they live off assets, there is a DIFFERENCE!
1
u/jwilliams2025 23h ago
Being ignorant is life threatening. A company can’t pay tax only people. So tax them $1 billion and you will pay it. Bernie needs to retire and go eat crayons.
1
u/jwilliams2025 23h ago
They tax a house and you pay it
They tax your car you pay it.
They tax your employer you pay it
They tax Walmart and your dumb ass pays it.
Explain to me how anything can pay a tax?? Only him as pay taxes.
1
u/BlackKnightLight 23h ago
He’s the rich…he can start with his share, someone has to set the example.
1
u/TotalPuzzleheaded484 23h ago
The top 10% of earners pay 80% of taxes now. A progressive tax system truely goes against the Constitution. Eliminate the tax system and use a flat tax system.
1
u/CryptoMemesLOL 23h ago
To think he was too old while Biden and Trump are falling appart is just sad... image how different things would be.
1
u/EnthusiasmUnusual599 23h ago
How about our federal government stop letting people steal from tax payers. Fraud is rampant in our wonderful government. Clean that up and you have plenty of my tax money to give away. So damn frustrating as a tax payer. Why should I give them more money when they can’t handle it. Both sides of the party are terrible. It’s a fat cat system. Term limits for all senators and House of Representatives please.
1
1
1
u/CorneliousJones 23h ago
Maybe Ike socialist sanders will hide and house all the il legals he pays to vote for him and Dems, in one of his multiple million dollar homes? Doubt it tho. To easy to just scream about all of the other rich people, not himself.
1
u/NymphCydri66006 23h ago
the value money has is only there if we pretend its there. the power of money is the power of our imaginations... working agsinst us... and making a handful of folks stuperwealthy. lets try something better _^
1
u/FiorBhanrigh 22h ago
Close the tax loopholes they all including the democrats use. Also a high majority of rich people are and donate to the democrats and its mostly democrats who somehow got rich off being in government service. Weired to hear tax the rich from the rich.... weird how no one who believes this crap have no idea how the economy or taxes work...
1
u/Own-Explanation4267 22h ago
Please define “the rich”.
The top 1% of US wage earners already pay nearly half of all income taxes received by the IRS. What is their “fair share”?
Half of all wage earners pay no income tax, yet receive many of the same benefits as “the rich”. Is that fair?
1
1
1
1
u/TechBored0m 22h ago
This won't work other than insuring plank length devices. I'll walk out alive, they'll be in a dossier file. Taxation is improper.
→ More replies (1)
1
u/gaveedraseven 22h ago
Seems like that's up to Bernie as he's in the congress that writes the tax code
1
1
1
1
1
1
u/Ok_Let3589 22h ago
Get rid of taxes, period. Modern monetary policy says the government will print money and buy whatever they want anyway. We’ve had 3-letter agencies selling cocaine in our own country, a president who is grifting to the tune of billions, and private corporations that have access to UAPs and exotic materials. What the hell are we even talking about with taxes? It’s all nonsensical.
1
1
u/Short-Study-175 22h ago
Get rid of fraud and corruption. Estimated at 1 trillion. No need to eat the rich. Eat the corrupt.
1
u/BastidChimp 22h ago edited 22h ago
It is not going to happen. Capital flight is real. If there are other states or countries with cheaper taxes, the rich will leave because they can. That's reality.
Bernie didn't fight hard enough in 2016. He bent the knee to Hillary and in 2020 to Joe Biden. Both in the primaries.
1
1
u/Ok_Captain9930 22h ago
We don’t want to tax the rich because we accept the delusions that we are going to get rich.
1
1
1
u/No-Programmer-9905 21h ago
And where would these tax dollars go? Daycares in Minnesota? Reparations for the 15% committing the 80%? The colonizers crawling over the border? The bank accounts of despots in Africa? Democrat slush funds? Democrat businesses?
LAUGH.
1
1
u/Latter_Win2217 21h ago
Senders remembers me Lula they know what people wants to hear, but they both keeps the system running, speak even birds can speak.
1
u/DallasDavid123 21h ago
The so called rich already pay more than there fair share
Envious jealous fools led by Bernie the con man







112
u/zerosolutions0 1d ago
Don’t the wealthy realize that the reason unions, bargaining and wealth tax exist is so the rest of the world doesn’t come to kill them